OurTupelo

Sean Tindell, commissioner of the Department of Public Safety, announced on Wednesday that he will run in the Republican primary next year for attorney general, Mississippi’s top legal official. 

Tindell launched his campaign Wednesday morning in Gulfport and began a statewide tour with stops in Jackson, Tupelo and Southaven. 

“Mississippi needs leaders who are focused less on petty disputes and more on working together and getting things done for the people we serve,” Tindell said. “That’s what I’m running for attorney general.” 

Tindell has led DPS since Gov. Tate Reeves appointed him to the post in 2020. Tindell previously served as a judge on the Mississippi Court of Appeals for three years and previously represented the Gulfport area in the state Senate for five years. 

Tindell said he is “uniquely qualified” to serve as attorney general because of his legislative, judicial and agency experience. He specifically pointed to his initiative to reduce the time the public waits at driver’s license bureaus and his efforts to reduce the autopsy backlog at the Mississippi Forensics Laboratory. 

“With me, there is no need for on-the-job training,” Tindell said. 

The state attorney general is the chief legal officer and advisor for the state, handles civil and criminal legal matters, represents state agencies and public officials in court and issues legal interpretations of state laws. 

If elected, Tindell said he plans to ask the Legislature to expand the scope of his office to handle more public corruption cases and work to provide public bodies with AG opinions more quickly. He also said he plans to eventually resign as commissioner to focus on campaigning for attorney general full time, though he doesn’t have a specific timeline for the resignation.

The attorney general slot will be an open seat because current Attorney General Lynn Fitch has announced she will run for governor next year. Tindell is the only candidate so far to announce he’s seeking the office. 

Henry Babour, a national GOP strategist, said on Mississippi Today’s “The Other Side” politics podcast that state Sen. Briggs Hopson, a Republican from Vicksburg who leads the Senate Appropriations Committee, will soon announce he’s running for attorney general. 

Here is a list of candidates who have announced they are running for statewide office in 2027: 

Governor: 

Lynn Fitch (R)

Andy Gipson (R)

Philip Gunn (R)

Lieutenant Governor: 

Michael Watson (R)

Secretary of State: 

Shuwaski Young (R)

Attorney General: 

Sean Tindell (R)

State Auditor: 

Nick Bain (R)

Daniel Sparks (R)

Army National Guard Command Sgt. Maj. Lee Stringer did not know the surprise awaiting him outside his Pearl office building. 

When Stringer stepped outside the 5th Squad office on a humid July morning, he was met with confetti canons, a cheering crowd and an oversized $200,000 check.

The money is a part of Lowe’s Hometown community impact grant – a five-year program centered around renovating and revitalizing community spaces. The money will be used to purchase and renovate a new space in Pearl for the nonprofit, which Stringer said could extend its reach to thousands of additional veterans and their families across the state.

Presenting the check was Tenesha Wells, a Lowe’s military recruiter and longtime 5th Squad volunteer. Stringer immediately cried when he saw her – embracing her as she stepped within arms reach. 

“All of that hit me at one time,” Stringer later said. “It was just such a sense of gratitude that we were noticed and appreciated.”

Stringer is a 26-year military veteran who oversees the Army National Guard’s largest battalion and serves as 5th Squad’s president. He started the group alongside three friends in 2016. The four initial members were a part of the 184th Sustainment Command, and wanted a way to stay connected as they began moving into different facets of the Army.

It was around this same time that a fellow guardsman was struggling to pay his light bill of around $200, Stringer recalled. The guardsman had reached out to several other veteran organizations and was met with denial or extended wait times. He couldn’t afford to wait that long.

Members of the unit gathered and paid the man’s bill the same day. The initial bill payment would become the blueprint for 5th Squad’s quick reaction funding – which allows struggling veterans to reach out and receive same day bill payments.

5th Squad would continue to provide financial assistance and garner more active volunteers as word spread of their mission – so much so that a space was leased in 2021 to keep up.  

The 1,200-square-foot building just south of downtown Jackson was mainly used for the group’s monthly meetings and for storage. 5th Squad would eventually move to a smaller space in Pearl two years later to host events for veterans and their families. The events served as a way to help veterans create a community – something Stringer struggled with when he left active duty. 

“Those guys that I went downrange with, I created that connection with them,” Stringer said. “When I came off active duty and was just working a civilian job I missed that. It’s like a part of you was missing.”

5th Squad began seeing upwards of 100 people at its weekly events and quickly outgrew the 1,000-square-foot building in Pearl. 

Stringer applied for Lowe’s Hometown grant program in March with a request for $100,000 to help find a larger space.  In June he was informed 5th Squad was a top 100 finalist out of 6,000 applicants nationwide. 

Lowe’s scheduled a consultation meeting with Stringer for its business cleaning and basic repair subscription the following month – an ordinary meeting in Stringer’s mind. It was only when Flowood Lowe’s store manager Cesare Della Valentina led Stringer outside and the cheers started that he realized what was happening.

The amount presented was double Stringer’s request, a surprise demonstrating the strength of his application, according to Lowe’s spokesperson Laurel Waller.

“Instead of making an investment that wouldn’t get the project across the finish line, Lowe’s decided to provide the needed investment to complete the project and allow the doors to open to veterans as soon as possible,” Lowe’s senior analyst Brett Baldeck stated. 

5th Squad is one of what Lowe’s hopes will be 100 large scale projects funded this year.

“The opportunities are just endless at this point and it’s all because of Lowe’s selecting us out of all those people to do it,” Stringer said.

The organization plans to move out by November once its current lease ends. Stringer hopes the new venue will allow 5th Squad to begin professional counseling and collaboration projects with other nonprofits.

State Auditor Shad White reported that over the last year, the state has recouped just $18,000 in additional welfare funds that now-disgraced officials misspent in a scandal that rocked the Mississippi Department of Human Services in 2020, bringing the total recovered funds to $1.5 million.

That represents less than 2% of the $96.3 million in federal public assistance funds White says officials frittered away from 2016 to 2020.

White gave this update in his July 31 Audit Exceptions Report, which details cases in which public funds have been misappropriated or spent incorrectly and must be repaid. It is published annually by state law.

White stressed in the latest report that his office identifies misspent funds, but the authority to collect those public monies rests with the office of Attorney General Lynn Fitch. A spokesperson says the AG’s office has been active and efficient in collecting misspent funds and prosecuting cases of public corruption.

White and Fitch, both statewide Republican officials, have been engaged in a long-running feud and both could be pursuing the office of governor in 2027. Fitch has announced her candidacy and political observers believe it is likely White also will run for the state’s top post.

In a summary of the 43-page report, White says the state still has a long way to go in recovering the funds misspent in the Mississippi welfare scandal.

The scandal received nationwide attention beginning in early 2020 and has resulted in seven convictions for various federal and state crimes related to the misspending of federal Temporary Assistance for Needy Families funds.

According to White’s office, $1.5 million of the $96.3 million in misspent TANF funds have been recovered in total, including the $18,000 recovered during the past fiscal year.

Separately, the auditor’s office issued 87 demands adding up to $10.9 million in 46 cases in fiscal year 2026. Almost $1.1 million of that has been recovered or returned to the appropriate public entity. 

The report states that since White became state auditor in 2018, and excluding the MDHS case, his office has issued demands in 103 cases totaling $15.8 million that has yet to be paid in full. Of those cases, White said his office referred 95 to the attorney general office to initiate litigation. The report states the attorney general’s office has only acted on eight of them.

“I do not have the power to prosecute our demands in court,” White said in the report’s summary. “A prosecutor must do that.”

White and Fitch were previously involved in a lawsuit over whether the attorney general or state auditor had the authority to sue on the state’s behalf to recover misspent taxpayer funds. In June, the Mississippi Supreme Court ruled unanimously that the power belonged to the attorney general.

Michelle Williams, chief of staff for Fitch, emailed a statement detailing the work of the attorney general. According to the statement, the auditor’s office referred 22 demand letters to the AG last year, she said. Of those, six were closed and 15 have corresponding criminal cases pending. 

In the first half of 2026, she said the AG closed one case, had five pending cases and one active civil matter.

On top of that, Williams said that in June the AG’s office indicted people in fraud cases totaling $12 million and has recovered over $101 million from fraud cases over Fitch’s entire tenure. 

“We will continue to litigate and prosecute these and all of our cases for the best interests of Mississippi,” Williams said.

The exceptions report also details that the state auditor issued over $7.4 million in demands to Management & Training Corporation, a prison staffing contractor, for understaffing at East Mississippi Correctional Facility, Marshall County Correctional Facility and Wilkinson Correctional Facility. The company was paid as if the company provided adequate staffing when it did not, the report said. It has repaid about $5.9 million.

“The office of the state Auditor continues to serve as a watchdog organization to ensure that tax dollars are protected, and we pledge to perform our jobs with integrity, honesty, and a commitment to excellence,” White wrote in the report.

The state Public Service Commission said Tuesday it plans to contest a recent decision by a chancery court placing a receiver over the long-struggling Holly Springs electric department.

After a hearing in Holly Springs last week, Lafayette County Chancery Judge Lawrence Little appointed Michael Watson, a consultant that the city hired last year, as receiver over the utility. The power provider, which serves about 12,000 customers across multiple counties in north Mississippi, has for years dealt with frequent and prolonged power outages due to deferred maintenance and low revenue. It also faced challenges billing its customers.

In response to those issues, the PSC, which regulates utilities in the state, last year deemed the utility unable to provide adequate service and petitioned the judge to place the Holly Springs electric department in a receivership, leading to last week’s hearing.

“For years, families served by (Holly Springs’ utility) have lost power for days at a time; food spoiling in refrigerators, medical equipment going dark, refrigerators and HVAC units burned out by a system that could not deliver steady service,” Northern District Public Service Commissioner Chris Brown said in a press release.

While glad Little removed control of the utility from the city, Brown disagreed with placing Watson in charge. The PSC is now planning to file a motion to reconsider, the release said, and will also request a forensic audit of the utility.

Brown argued placing Watson in charge “does not change who has been running this utility.” Watson started as a consultant for the city nine months ago, according to court filings. City officials said after last week’s hearing that the system has already seen improvements, specifically with outages, since Watson came on board.

Little released his written order on Monday, marking the start date of Watson’s receivership. The order details the receiver’s powers and responsibilities in running the utility. Among those, the order places all assets owned by the electric department under the receiver’s control. Watson will be paid from the system’s revenue in an amount Little will determine later.

“The Receiver shall assume and maintain sole control and responsibility for the operation and management of the affairs of the HSUD electric system to preserve its assets and serve the best interests of its customers,” Little’s order said, adding that the receiver has broad authority to carry out his duties.

“This includes the immediate authority to correct system failures, rebuild unmaintained substations, reclaim overgrown rights-of-way via robust vegetation management, and stabilize the down (meter) network and billing cycles.”

The order gives Watson “sole discretion” over the department’s employment and contracts. It also prevents Holly Springs officials from interfering “in any way” with the receiver’s work.

Little’s order does not set a time length for Watson’s receivership, leaving it in the court’s discretion as to when it will transfer control of the utility either back to the city or to another party. While in charge, Watson has to file status reports with the court at least every 45 days.

The order also prohibits the city from transferring any payments in lieu of taxes from the utility to Holly Springs without Little’s approval, as city officials have done in the past.

Alleged mishandling of those payments are part of a federal lawsuit Holly Springs is facing from the Tennessee Valley Authority, which has had a wholesale power contract with the city since the 1930s. As of last week, the city was behind on its payments to TVA by $18 million.

The parties met as part of a settlement conference on Monday in federal court. In a Wednesday order, U.S. Magistrate Judge Jane Virden scheduled a final pretrial conference for July 13.

As temperatures climbed into the triple digits on Monday, tenants at the Addison Place Apartments Homes in west Jackson said they haven’t had running water for over a month. JXN Water, the city’s court-appointed drinking water provider, disconnected the complex after the owner accumulated six figures’ worth of water bill debt.

WLBT first reported the disconnection on July 23. Residents who spoke to Mississippi Today on Monday said they haven’t had water for even longer than that.

“You don’t realize how much you need water until you don’t have it,” Trendarius Burns, an Addison Place resident who lives with his three sons, said.

Since the disconnection, Burns said management has brought cases of water to residents — about two a week — and that maintenance workers will come by to pour water into the back of toilets so that they can flush.

But the father, who works at Continental Tires and pays $800 a month for a two-bedroom unit, said he and his children have to go to a friend or family member’s place to take showers. On top of money he’s spending on bottled water, Burns said he’s had to spend a lot more on food — about $40 to $50 a day — because it’s difficult to cook at home. He said he’s planning to move soon.

“They’re some good apartments, we ain’t never had no problem. It’s just the water,” Burns said. “It’s just uncalled for.”

Since last summer, JXN Water has disconnected apartment complexes where owners have accumulated large amounts of debt on their water bill and haven’t cooperated in negotiating a payment plan.

During an Aug. 6 meeting, Ward 5 Councilman Vernon Hartley, who represents the area, brought the matter to the attention of a City Council committee.

“They don’t have running water?” a surprised Ward 1 Councilman Ashby Foote responded, adding that it was “appalling” an apartment owner would let tenants who pay their rent lose water.

New Jersey-based company Jackson Addison SPV LLC owns the property, according to Hinds County tax records. The complex’s management did not respond to a request for comment. The city of Jackson also did not respond to multiple emails asking about the situation.

Robert Brunson, the city’s manager of Code Enforcement, said at the Aug. 6 meeting that 45 residents at the complex didn’t have water while 16 did. He estimated the complex’s owner owed over $300,000 on its water bill, but that the property manager told him they wanted to dispute the charges. Brunson added his department dealt with other unaddressed issues with the same complex last year.

Despite the public health concern, JXN Water’s general policy is to disclose few details about individual accounts. In this instance, the utility wouldn’t say when it disconnected water to the apartment or how much the owner owes. JXN Water did say Tuesday it has been in contact with the owner’s legal team but “to no avail.”

“There still has not been a payment initiated on the account,” JXN Water spokesperson Aisha Carson said. “There has been meter tampering on the property. So, the water at the property has been shut off several times over the past two months.”

At the City Council meeting in August, Jackson’s Office of Code Enforcement said it was looking to have a hearing on the issue in the city’s environmental court on Aug. 25.

Hartley, the city councilman, said Tuesday it was frustrating how widespread the issue of landlords not providing essential services in Jackson has become. He added that the city is working on a map and tracking the system to rate all of Jackson’s apartments based on inspections to flag potential issues before they arise.

“We’re trying to delineate and find out which (apartment complexes) are more susceptible to putting their occupants into a public health situation,” he said.

Mississippi lawmakers are expected to debate taxes and regulations around lithium in the 2027 legislative session, determining whether the state becomes a major producer of the mineral critical to battery production. 

The Mississippi Development Authority published a report in May arguing Mississippi has the potential to engage in large-scale lithium production, but lawmakers have yet to decide taxes, incentives and environmental regulations for the companies that could develop the industry. 

The state sits atop the Smackover Formation, a large swath of porous rock that contains mineral-rich solutions known as brines. Companies would pump mineral-rich brine from underground, remove the lithium using a process called direct lithium extraction, or DLE, and then return the remaining brine to the water table. 

Tim Palmer, a geologist at the Mississippi Department of Environmental Quality, used coffee as a way to compare DLE with solar evaporation, a more traditional method of lithium production. 

“I can take my coffee, I can run it through a system and it’ll concentrate the coffee — that’s what DLE does,” Palmer said. “Whereas (with evaporation) I’d have to take a bunch of coffee and impound it at the surface… and you have to wait for it to concentrate.” 

Lithium — a key mineral in rechargeable batteries used for electric vehicles, consumer electronics and some military technologies — is labeled a critical mineral by the U.S. Department of the Interior. The majority of lithium used in the U.S. is shipped from overseas, largely from China, so domestic production is seen by state and federal leaders as both an economic boon and a matter of national security. 

“This is really not only an economic opportunity for Mississippi, it’s an opportunity for Mississippi to help once again provide for our nation’s defense,” Gov. Tate Reeves said at an Aug. 5 news conference. 

Domestically, lithium could serve as a large source of revenue. Mississippi Development Authority Executive Director Bill Cork told the crowd at the 2026 Mississippi Natural Resources Summit that lithium extraction’s potential economic benefits for the state should be a key part of the narrative that the project’s champions tell. 

“Mississippi can make some money to help the real problems we have,” Cork said. “Things like intergenerational poverty, rural health care and a number of other things.”

Whether lithium production becomes more profitable in Mississippi will depend partly on market conditions and state policy. 

With ongoing volatility in lithium prices, as well as high startup costs for DLE projects, the MDA suggests creating financial incentives to attract lithium companies. Among its proposals are a 2.5% royalty that scales down if prices decrease and a six-year holiday on severance taxes and royalties that companies pay to the state and county upon extraction for the industry’s pilot companies. 

While potentially attracting industry, concerns around similar domestic lithium projects suggest that financial incentives for companies may increase the burden of risk that Mississippians bear. Groups critical of lithium extraction argue state legislators should consider severance taxes based on revenue to protect communities from the economic uncertainty around lithium as the industry develops. 

Arkansas, which also sits atop the Smackover Formation, adopted a different tax model in 2025. The state does not have a distinct tax on lithium but taxes $2.75 per 1,000 barrels of saltwater or brine extracted, a tax model that does not scale with industry revenue. Critics there argue the relatively low tax rate leaves the state vulnerable if lithium prices decline.

Mississippi already levies severance taxes on resources such as oil, natural gas and timber, but state law does not establish one for lithium production. 

Reeves indicated at a recent news conference that he wants no severance tax on lithium in Mississippi. 

“I’m okay if we don’t tax it because I believe pretty strongly if you want more of something, you tax it less,” Reeves said. “I’m sure there will be a debate and discussion about specific severance taxes if and when the legislature comes in, but zero is okay with me.” 

The environmental impact of lithium mining in the state also depends on legislative guidance. DLE is an umbrella term for several technologies that extract lithium and other metal ions directly from brine, greatly reducing land use, water use and carbon dioxide emissions compared with traditional extraction methods. However, researchers at Columbia University argue that more research is needed to determine how DLE affects freshwater resources. 

Different DLE technologies have different environmental impacts. 

Palmer said he expects Mississippi to use a variety of DLE processes, and the decision on which process to use would be left to industry partners. 

“These decisions are made by industry because it’s all about economics, and so, Mississippi isn’t going to tell industry what process to use,” Palmer said. “These are very expensive things to do. … whatever is the most cost-effective process, that’s what’s going to be applied.” 

Palmer said it is important to begin domestic lithium extraction now. 

“Understanding (how to extract lithium) is a problem for 2026,” Palmer said. “But it’ll take 100 years if we don’t start trying to figure out how we actually take metals out of solutions.” 

The Mississippi Development Authority indicated that clarifying laws, acquiring data and creating economic incentives for companies are the three major pillars for beginning lithium production in the state. 

High school came with more responsibility and less accountability for Josiah Ulukita. Courses were much harder, teachers were less strict about attendance, and it was easier to skip school with friends or go on his phone during class, said 16-year-old Ulukita, who attends Kaimuki High School in Honolulu. 

He went from easily passing middle school to failing freshman English and social studies. After missing roughly half of his freshman year due to poor attendance, he found out he needed to repeat ninth grade. Ashamed, he began to skip more school, he said — until his counselor warned him that he may not graduate on time. 

“I was acing all my classes, and then I hit freshman year,” Ulukita said. “I thought it was going to be easy.”

Throughout the country, states and school districts approach retention — often considered a last resort to catch students up academically — in very different ways. In some states, like Hawaii, schools often wait until ninth grade or later to retain, or hold back, students. Other states, like Mississippi and Florida, tend to retain students at much younger ages, between kindergarten through third grade, according to numbers from 2021-22, the most recent year for which national data was available. 

As concern about student performance nationally intensifies, a growing number of states are mandating this approach: More than two dozen states now have laws requiring or allowing schools to retain third grade students who are not reading at grade level, according to an analysis from the Education Commission of the States, a nonprofit that tracks state legislation in the U.S. 

Despite these laws, the rate of students who were retained in school fell across the U.S. from the 2011-12 to 2021-22 school years, according to data from the federal Office for Civil Rights compiled by the journalism organization Big Local News in partnership with The Hechinger Report. Overall, very few students are held back each year: Less than 2 percent of students in the U.S. repeated a grade level in 2021-22, down from about 3 percent of students a decade prior. (The Office for Civil Rights, the only source for consistent data across all states, is now eight months behind in releasing new data.) 

The research on retention is mixed — there’s little consensus on whether retention can catch students up to grade level. Historically, most studies indicated that students who had to repeat a grade often benefited very little and had long-term negative consequences. Research from the past decade complicates that picture: Younger students may see some positive effects from retention if schools are also combining it with high-intensity tutoring and support, some studies have shown.

“If the retention happens in earlier grades and is combined with help — not just a threat, but some kind of positive intervention — the results, at least in the short-run, tend to be good,” said Dan Goldhaber, director of the Center for Education Data and Research at the University of Washington.

There is less proof that students in middle and high school, like Ulukita, ultimately benefit from repeating a grade.

“The evidence suggests that it leads to higher rates of student disengagement from schooling, it leads to higher rates of high school dropouts, less likelihood of high school graduations, and it leads to lower likelihood of enrolling in college. Basically, worse outcomes,” said Umut Ozek, a researcher and senior economist at the policy think tank Rand Corp., who has studied retention.

In every year measured, schools in the South held students back more than any other region, according to the data. Boys were held back more than girls, and Black boys were retained at nearly three times the rate of white boys — a gap that did not narrow over the decade even as retention fell. 

In Hawaii, roughly 1 in 10 freshmen in public high schools had to repeat ninth grade in the 2021-22 school year. That was more than double the national rate for this group of students.   

In the state, freshmen must earn five credits — the equivalent of five year-long classes — to move on to 10th grade. Students and teachers attribute the spike in ninth grade retention to those strict credit requirements, along with more difficult coursework and increased peer pressure to skip class and dodge assignments.

Schools work to avoid holding students back by offering summer school, counseling, personalized learning plans and other resources, Hawaii Department of Education Deputy Superintendent Heidi Armstrong said in a statement. Students may be held back when they’re struggling to make academic progress and earn enough credits to advance to the next grade, she said. 

“The Department’s goal is to ensure students are prepared for continued academic success and remain on track toward earning a high school diploma,” Armstrong said, adding that schools decide to hold students back on a case-by-case basis. 

Mississippi has taken a markedly different approach. In 2013, as part of an overhaul of literacy instruction, the state introduced a policy to retain third graders if they couldn’t pass the reading portion of the state’s English Language Arts assessment.

Rachel Canter, an education policy expert who helped craft the 2013 Literacy-Based Promotion Act, said Mississippi lawmakers looked to Florida in particular, where former Gov. Jeb Bush made ending “social promotion” — the practice of passing students because of their age — one of his signature policies.

“The Legislature was desperate,” Canter said. “The argument that won was, ‘We have to do something, and we know how harmful it is when kids pass with no skills.’”

The state’s third grade retention policy has had a trickle-down effect: Retentions in Mississippi are concentrated in kindergarten through second grade, too. 

Researchers such as Canter say that’s because the literacy legislation established more monitoring and higher standards in those grades as well.

That holds true at Western Line School District, a small district with schools on the banks of the Mississippi River. Western Line held back 68 students in kindergarten through third grade during the 2021-22 school year, compared to 56 students in all other grades combined, according to the Big Local News/Hechinger analysis. 

Not all of those retentions are tied to reading, Superintendent Lawrence Hudson said, but the policy raised the bar for students in early grades.

“We want to make sure kids are successful for the rest of their life,” he said. “We know if children have deficits at younger grades, they’ll get to third grade with those deficits.” He added: “The longer you wait, the harder it is to clear those deficiencies.”

But Canter said students don’t automatically improve when they’re retained. To help students, schools have to get them the academic support they need in that year they repeat. The decision to retain a student is difficult, she said, but combined with intervention, it can pay dividends. 

“Any time a child is retained, it is a signal that we have not done what we needed to do as adults,” Canter said. But the retention policy paired with additional support has “done great things for kids,” she said. 

Yet some educators worry that, even in relatively well-funded school districts, resources to provide that support are falling away. Shana Richards has been a school counselor for 19 years in North Carolina, which holds back more students in ninth grade than in any other grade. 

“You used to have teachers that would stay after school, provide tutoring,” said Richards, who now works at A&T Four Middle College, an all-boys public high school on the campus of North Carolina A&T State University in Greensboro. “But now those people are having to leave to go to another job when the school day ends.”

The stipends for educators to provide after-school programming dried up years ago, she said, and the buses that used to carry students home from their after-school activities no longer run, either.

Richards helped design a program for her school’s incoming ninth graders that she hoped would help reduce the need for supports that are now harder to come by. She applied for a grant from the NEA Foundation to help fund the program, an expanded version of the summer orientation the school was already doing. 

The program, which just completed its second year, is called “Welcome to the Brotherhood” and primarily serves the population with the highest retention rates: Black boys. Students learn study skills and hear about academic expectations from their English and math teachers. They also have time to make friends and tour the college campus that surrounds their school.

Richards meets with every student before the program begins to get a sense of their anxieties and where they might need extra support, and she meets with them again in the first month of the school year to get a sense of any emerging problems.

“We know if we can get them to and through ninth grade,” Richards said, “then they have a higher chance of actually staying until graduation.” 

In Washington state, more students were held back just before graduation, in 12th grade, than at any other grade, according to the data from 2011-12 to 2021-22. That’s not because of any state policy though; decisions are made at a district level. 

Still, Liz Trautman, the executive director of the Washington affiliate of Stand for Children, an advocacy organization that works to boost high school graduation rates, said she was not surprised by the trend.

“I would argue and suggest that when we see those high rates of retention in senior year, we’re actually seeing a cumulative effect of missed opportunities to intervene and to support students that started much, much earlier,” Trautman said.  

Washington officials say retained students include those who were behind in credits for a variety of reasons, including from absences related to medical issues or involvement in the juvenile justice system. Many are also enrolled in transition programs for students who receive special education services and are counted as 12th graders until they’re 22 years old or exit the program, officials said.

Daniel Lee, who has spent 14 years as a counselor at Garfield High School in Seattle, said a high student-to-counselor ratio means counselors aren’t able to work with students and parents as closely as they would like to ensure students have everything they need to meet requirements before 12th grade.

The American School Counselor Association recommends a 250:1 ratio. Washington’s was 364:1 in the 2024-25 school year. 

“In order for us to be effective in all facets of our job, not just interventions, but every aspect of our job — whether it’s college and career-readiness or social-emotional health — all of that hinges on the 250:1 ratio,” he said.

But, he said, counselors check in every quarter with students who are struggling to find out what’s hindering them. That could include finding ways to help them attend regularly or setting up mental health support if that’s the barrier, he said.

Tutoring and summer classes are available for those who aren’t grasping the material or need to recover credits, he said, though access to them is uneven.

“They do have an incentive to finish,” Lee said. “It’s pretty rare to say, ‘I am not doing it.’”

Ulukita, the high schooler in Hawaii who repeated ninth grade, is on track to graduate with the rest of his peers in 2028. Now a junior, he was able to earn the credits he needed to complete both his freshman and sophomore years through additional courses, after-school work and a better attendance record. 

Said Ulukita: “You’ve got to lock in more, do all your classes, make sure you get all your credits — and graduate on time.”

Contact editor Caroline Preston at 212-870-8965, via Signal at CarolineP.83 or on email at preston@hechingerreport.org.

This story about being held back was produced by Big Local News and The Hechinger Report, a nonprofit, independent news organization focused on inequality and innovation in education, in collaboration with The Assembly in North Carolina, Honolulu Civil Beat, Mississippi Today and The Seattle Times. 

The data analysis was conducted by Eric Sagara, senior data journalist with Big Local News. Reporting was contributed by Megan Tagami, Ariel Gilreath, Devna Bose, Carli Brosseau and Denisa R. Superville. Sign up for the Hechinger newsletter. Learn more about Big Local News and how it supports local journalists.

The Saints played their first exhibition and college football is slightly more than two weeks old. We are on the cusp of football and the AP preseason poll is out. Ole Miss is No. 9. Too high? To low? The Clevelands discuss, plus Rick remembers the only Mississippi team to ever play in the Little League World Series, which turns 74 this month and saturates ESPN’s August programming.

TUPELO – Mississippi residents who spoke on Tuesday at the first of several public hearings on redistricting around the state urged lawmakers to not redraw electoral maps, calling the effort a needless power grab aimed at diluting Black political power in a state with a sordid racial history.  

The Republican-dominated joint House and Senate committee on redistricting kicked off its slate of public hearings in a nearly packed room at Itawamba Community College in Tupelo. Leaders of the committee say the hearings will allow lawmakers to solicit feedback before making recommendations on new voting maps to the full Legislature in a likely special session this fall. 

The push to redraw maps comes after the U.S. Supreme Court issued a decision in the Louisiana Callais case in May. The ruling gutted part of the Voting Rights Act and, by removing protections for minority districts, cleared the way for Republican-controlled state legislatures to redraw political lines in their favor. 

President Donald Trump, who is working to protect a slim GOP majority in Congress in this November’s midterm elections, has pressured states his party controls to redraw maps, and many have already complied.

In Mississippi, the joint House and Senate committee is expected to do the bulk of the work of redrawing Mississippi’s legislative, judicial and congressional voting lines. But with Mississippi having had its federal midterm primaries months ago, it appears unlikely congressional maps would be redrawn for November’s federal election.

Only 10 of the 20 members on the state joint committee were in attendance on Tuesday.

The room was dominated by Mississippi residents who oppose redistricting. Many of those who spoke said the Callais decision doesn’t require Mississippi to redraw its maps, and that doing so would create confusion for voters and impose a financial cost on localities. They also said hard-won progress to increase Black representation in Mississippi since the Jim Crow era would be eradicated. 

The Reverend Jeffrey Gladney, pastor of a Church in Shannon, said redrawn maps would “eliminate Black districts” and attack “Black voices that represent the Black community.”

“If maps are redrawn, they will split neighborhoods, divide communities, take away resources from already weakened communities,” Gladney said. 

Jim Newman, chairman of the Lee County Democratic Party, said the Legislature should redistrict after the next U.S. Census in 2030 rather than rushing to redraw maps at President Trump’s urging as states such as Texas have done. 

“Y’all are looking for a power grab, plain and simple,” Newman said. “It didn’t have to happen. But the president asked for it, and by God, everybody bends over to take care of the president. And it’s not any different here in Mississippi.”  

Teresa Roberts said redistricting would impact the social and economic well-being of “marginalized people.” 

“These are people who need us, who need you, and you are going to take away what little strength they already have,” Roberts said. “Shame on you.”

Katie Gilbert said she came straight from work to attend Tuesday’s hearing. She was raised in Tupelo and went to Tupelo High School. She said redistricting would contribute to the “brain drain” flight of young people out of Mississippi.

“We wonder a lot of times why we have a brain drain in Mississippi, why a lot of educated young folks leave this state. It’s because of decisions like this that are leaving us in the past,” Gilbert said. “Mississippi has a very dark history, but we do not need to continue on with a dark future. Equitable maps lead to a stronger Mississippi.”

Walter Jones said his family lived down the street in Chicago from the family of Emmett Till, a Black youth whose murder in Mississippi helped spark the Civil Rights Movement. He said moved to Mississippi because of the progress the state had made in overcoming its history of racial discrimination, but he now wonders whether he made the wrong move.

“I came down here because things have changed. Mississippi was becoming a great place to stay. People was people. Everybody like everybody,” Jones said. “If this is what y’all want to do to Mississippi after all the hurt and struggles y’all went through to get to where we’re at today, I made a bad decision.”  

Only one person in attendance, Mike Walker, appeared to speak in favor of redistricting.

“All I’ve heard up here today is bashing these elected representatives for what they’re trying to do,” Walker said. “So let me ask you, what color is your soul? It’s a soul thing people. It ain’t Black or white. It’s a soul thing.” 

Many civil rights leaders, Black lawmakers and voting rights advocates believe the hearings are a pretext for the Legislature moving to dismantle majority-Black districts and weakening Black political power in the state.

Democratic Rep. Rickey Thompson of Shannon, who is not on the joint committee but attended the hearing, said he doubted his Republican colleagues would take community feedback into account.

“They already have their plans together,” Thompson told Mississippi Today. “They’re just going through the motions.”

Republican leaders believe that when the U.S. Supreme Court issued its ruling in the Callais decision, it ended an improper practice of allowing for the consideration of race in drawing political maps.  

Since the Callais decision, some GOP leaders in Mississippi and Washington, D.C., have called for heavy partisan gerrymandering, including redrawing of incumbent U.S. Rep. Bennie Thompson’s district to help oust him, the state’s only Black member of Congress and only Democrat.

Cliff Johnson, a University of Mississippi law school professor who is the Democratic nominee challenging Republican U.S. Rep. Trent Kelly in this year’s midterms, attended the hearing and mingled with attendees. He said the hearing showed Mississippians didn’t want a redistricting process that inflamed racial and partisan divides.

“I thought it was very powerful to see people stand in front of a bunch of legislators and ask to have a say. My sense as a lifelong Mississippian is that our diversity is such a strength,” Johnson said. “The notion of having representatives chosen by a cross-section of our population is something that makes us stronger.” 

The committee is encouraging the public to participate in future hearings. The public can offer comments at any of the seven remaining public hearings, or submit written comments to Ted Booth, the committee’s attorney, at ted.booth@peer.ms.gov.

Below is the schedule of the future planned redistricting hearings. Each will start at 6 p.m. 

• Aug. 27 at Northwest Mississippi Community College in Southaven 
• Sept. 1 at Delta State University in Cleveland 
• Sept. 8 at Alcorn State University in Natchez 
• Sept.10 at Meridian Community College in Meridian 
• Sept. 17 at the University of Southern Mississippi in Hattiesburg 
• Sept. 22 at Mississippi Gulf Coast Community College in Gulfport 
• Oct. 1 at the state Capitol in Jackson

Mississippi Today is pleased to welcome Blake Barnes as its new multimedia producer.

Barnes joins a multimedia team responsible for collaborating with reporters and editors to produce social videos based on Mississippi Today’s reporting. He will also contribute to the production of the newsroom’s video podcasts, as well as long-form video projects. He began work Monday.

The hire reflects Mississippi Today’s commitment to reaching audiences and creating impact across multiple mediums.

Barnes most recently served as a producer at Mississippi Public Broadcasting, where he directed Everlasting: The New Generation.

He grew up on a farm in Ludlow, Mississippi with a family of storytellers. He attended East Central Community College, then Delta State University. He’s called Jackson home for the last five years.

“I’ve always loved Mississippi,” said Barnes. “This is my home, and I think telling stories is a way I can help push the state forward. I’m looking forward to the opportunities Mississippi Today will offer me in this way, and continuing to tell and to preserve these local Mississippi stories.”